What Motivates us to Work? Is Money Alone Enough? (Part 2)

Joel Staff Management 08 Jun 2014


Keeping employees motivated is crucial to any business. Getting the best out of staff is a constant hurdle for managers and employers alike. While pay rises and bonuses are very useful incentives, you cannot consistently rely on handing out big cheques to keep employees happy and performing well...

bait

In my last blog I discussed the importance of giving meaning to tasks and how it can drastically increase an employee's motivation to perform.

This week I'll cover the final two experiments of Ariely's research. These explore how feedback impacts our desire to work, and the impact of pride upon the valuation of our own efforts. 

Experiment 2 - Paperwork

In the second experiment, each participant was given a sheet of paper covered in random letters and asked to highlight any pairings (where two identical letters were next each other). As with the previous experiment, for every sheet of paper completed the subject was rewarded - and the amount of money they received decreased after each completion until they refused to participate. When handing their completed sheets in the participants were divided into three groups:

  • Group 1 - Each sheet is taken by a researcher, read through and placed on a pile (Acknowledged)
  • Group 2 - Each sheet is taken by a researcher, not even looked at and placed on a pile (Ignored)
  • Group 3 - Each sheet is taken by a researcher, and placed into a shredder (Shredded)
shred
 
The results showed that those who were in Group 1 (acknowledged) completed sheets down to a very small amount of money. Those in Group 3 (shredded) stopped much earlier, and those who were in Group 2 (ignored) stopped only slightly later than Group 3.

Ariely concluded that getting recognition for your work no matter how slight, is an important motivator -and that when ignored completely it can have almost have as negative an effect as having your work shredded right before your eyes. 

Experiment 3 - Ikea Effect

Anyone who has wrestled with the infamous Swedish flat pack furniture knows that it is not always of the highest quality. However, the pride and satisfaction of ignoring decoding the instructions and constructing it yourself often means it ranks much higher in your estimations than other fixtures and fittings in your home. This is the Ikea Effect, and it is the base principal for this final experiment.

crane 

Ariely again gathered a group of willing participants. This time, half the group was tasked with building origami sculptures. They were provided with paper, instructions and accompanying diagrams. Once they had finished their creations, the whole group was then told that they could purchase these paper sculptures from the research team and were each asked what they would pay.

The results showed that the half of the group who built the figures valued their work much higher than those who were observing.

The same experiment was conducted again but roles of the participants reversed, however this time the instructions were removed and those building could only use the diagrams as a guide.

Consequently, the sculptures created were much worse than those before, and this was reflected in the valuations given by those observing. However, when asked to estimate the worth of their own work the builders placed a much higher price tag than in the previous test.

In their eyes, the task had been much harder and their valuation echoed the extra effort.

Overall

These final experiments again highlight the significance of meaning, but also how garnering recognition from a manager impacts our desire to work. If we feel appreciated then our desire to perform increases, a simple fact but one that is often overlooked in many workplaces. Furthermore, when a task requires a great deal of time and effort on our behalf then the product of those efforts is valued accordingly.

It is human nature for us to take pride in our creations. The more we sweat over a task the greater value it will hold in our minds regardless of the quality of that origami model or report. Employers should recognise the importance of acknowledging their staffs efforts and provide encouragement where it is due.

Collectively Ariely's experiments have shown that moneteray rewards alone are simply an insufficient method for keeping employees satisfied. In reality, people need so much more:

  • Meaning
  • Creation
  • Pride
  • Challenge
  • Identity
  • Ownership
  • Acknowledgement

Consider how you can incorporate these elements into your business. Build healthy relationships with your staff, provide them with a sense of pride and value and you'll soon increase both the productivity and happiness of your employees.